Introduction
In recent years, the conversation around neurodiversity, especially in the workplace, has shifted from focusing solely on deficits to embracing the strengths of individuals with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD). This blog post is based on the research paper “Navigating the Duality of Autism in the Workplace: Understanding the Lived Experiences of Autistic Professionals” by Michelle Blood Checketts, published in September 2024. The study investigates how autistic professionals navigate the duality of their strengths and challenges at work and how organizations can support them in this process. Let’s delve into the research findings and explore the implications for both autistic professionals and their workplaces.
The Dual Nature of Autism: Challenges and Strengths
Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is a neurodevelopmental condition that affects social communication, interaction, and behavior. While it is often associated with deficits, such as challenges in social skills and communication, autism also brings unique strengths like attention to detail, creativity, hyper-focus, and logical reasoning. The neurodiversity movement emphasizes this diversity, encouraging organizations to view autism not just as a disability but as a valuable source of talent.
Michelle Blood Checketts’ study explores this duality of autism in the workplace, a concept that recognizes both the strengths and the challenges autistic professionals face. The study focuses on how autistic professionals manage these dualities, how their experiences differ by gender, and how organizations can help them thrive.
Research Approach: Understanding Lived Experiences
To capture the real-world experiences of autistic professionals, the study employs a qualitative, inductive approach. The researcher conducted 11 interviews (and plans for 40-50 total) with individuals diagnosed with ASD or those who identify as autistic. These interviews provided insights into how autistic employees navigate their dual nature in professional environments, including their career challenges, strengths, and the role of special interests in career choices.
The study specifically focuses on professionals with Level 1 autism (formerly referred to as Asperger’s Syndrome or high-functioning autism), as these individuals are more likely to be employed in professional settings and have the language skills necessary for interviews.
Key Themes in the Lived Experiences of Autistic Professionals
1. Organizational Justice: A Double-Edged Sword
One of the core themes that emerged from the study is the importance of organizational justice for autistic professionals. Many participants described how a strong sense of justice and fairness impacts their workplace experiences. While this need for fairness can sometimes create challenges—such as difficulties in moving on from perceived injustices—it also empowers them to fight for justice in the workplace, advocating for equal pay and opportunities for their colleagues.
Autistic professionals are less likely to be placated by partial justice. For example, if one form of justice, like distributive justice (fairness in pay), is lacking, they won’t feel compensated by procedural fairness (fair decision-making processes). Autistic individuals tend to follow rules strictly, and this tendency extends to their expectations of fairness.
Interestingly, many participants expressed that their heightened sense of justice stemmed from hyper-empathy, a trait that is especially prominent in autistic women. While empathy is not typically associated with autism, the study shows that many autistic women possess deep empathy, which helps them become strong advocates for fairness and equity in the workplace.
2. Gender Differences: The Experience of Autistic Women
The study also uncovers significant gender differences in the experiences of autistic professionals, particularly the unique challenges faced by autistic women. Women on the autism spectrum often experience a tension between societal expectations of femininity and the traits typically associated with autism. For example, the direct communication style and logical reasoning that are common in autism can conflict with expectations for women to be warm, nurturing, and indirect in their communication.
To navigate these conflicting expectations, many autistic women engage in masking—the act of concealing their autistic traits to “fit in” with neurotypical colleagues. While masking can help them avoid stigma, it often leads to feelings of inauthenticity and burnout. One participant summed it up by saying, “I don’t girl well,” highlighting the struggle between their natural behavior and societal norms.
However, masking isn’t the whole story. The study also reveals that many autistic women bring a unique strength to the workplace: hyper-empathy. Some participants mentioned that they could deeply empathize with colleagues and clients, which helped them excel in leadership and advocacy roles. This empathy often contrasts with the stereotype that autistic individuals lack emotional understanding.
The duality of being both female and autistic adds an extra layer of complexity to their professional experiences. These women often feel they are at the intersection of multiple forms of marginalization, struggling to navigate both gender and neurodiversity stereotypes.
3. The Role of Special Interests in Career Path Choices
Another important theme in the research is the role of special interests in shaping the careers of autistic professionals. Many individuals on the autism spectrum have deep, focused interests that can drive their career paths. For some, these special interests narrow their career options, making it challenging to find a job that aligns with their passions. If their chosen career path doesn’t align with their interests, they may struggle to find meaningful work.
On the flip side, participants who were able to incorporate their special interests into their careers reported higher levels of job satisfaction and organizational loyalty. Some participants mentioned that their deep focus and knowledge in their special interest areas allowed them to excel in their roles, whether in fields like city planning, social work, or television production.
These findings highlight the need for organizations to be flexible in allowing autistic employees to engage with their special interests. This approach not only helps employees thrive but also increases their long-term commitment to the organization.
Implications for Organizations: Creating an Inclusive Workplace
The study offers several actionable insights for organizations looking to support autistic professionals in navigating the duality of their strengths and challenges.
1. Recognize the Duality of Autism
Organizations need to move beyond a deficit-based view of autism and adopt a holistic approach that acknowledges both strengths and challenges. Autistic employees bring valuable traits to the workplace, such as attention to detail, creativity, and dedication, but they also face unique challenges related to communication, social interaction, and sensory sensitivities. Focusing solely on one side of the duality risks undermining the full potential of autistic employees.
Managers should aim to support autistic employees in converting their challenges into strengths. For instance, an employee’s adherence to routines can be seen as rigidity, but with the right support, it can become a valuable asset for maintaining consistency and reliability.
2. Foster Organizational Justice
Autistic professionals have a heightened sense of organizational justice, making it essential for managers to ensure fairness in all aspects of the workplace, including pay, promotion, and decision-making processes. Autistic employees are likely to feel alienated if they perceive any form of injustice, which could lead to higher turnover rates or disengagement.
Importantly, managers need to recognize that autistic employees value all forms of justice and that failing in one area (e.g., distributive justice) cannot be compensated by fairness in other areas (e.g., procedural justice).
3. Support Gender-Specific Needs
Autistic women face unique challenges in the workplace, often stemming from their intersectional identities of being both neurodiverse and female. Organizations should be aware of the pressure many autistic women feel to engage in masking behaviors, which can lead to burnout. Providing a supportive environment that values authenticity and individual differences can help alleviate this pressure.
Managers can also leverage the hyper-empathy displayed by many autistic women by creating opportunities for them to take on roles that involve leadership and advocacy. By recognizing and supporting these strengths, organizations can help autistic women flourish in their careers.
4. Encourage Engagement with Special Interests
Autistic professionals often thrive when they are able to engage with their special interests at work. Managers should create opportunities for these employees to incorporate their passions into their roles, whether by allowing them to focus on specific projects or offering roles that align with their interests. By doing so, organizations can foster long-term loyalty and job satisfaction among autistic employees.
Conclusion: Embracing the Duality for a More Inclusive Workplace
Michelle Blood Checketts’ study provides a comprehensive look at how autistic professionals navigate the duality of their strengths and challenges in the workplace. By understanding the importance of organizational justice, recognizing gender differences, and allowing employees to engage with their special interests, organizations can create an environment where autistic professionals can thrive.
Embracing the duality of autism allows companies to unlock the full potential of their autistic employees, contributing to a more diverse, innovative, and inclusive workforce. Rather than viewing autism as either a disability or a strength, organizations must acknowledge that it is both—and that’s where the real potential for growth and success lies.
Source: